Investing Environment
Investors went into Q3 waiting for an all-clear sign on inflation that would let the Fed finally cut interest rates. Economic data during the period pointed in that direction, with soft readings on employment and inflation.
Consumer price index (CPI) data generally trended lower over the quarter, with the most recent August core CPI reading showing a 3.2% year-over-year increase, the lowest since 2021. Meanwhile, non-farm payrolls rose by just 114,000 jobs in July, well below the consensus expectation of 175,000, and the unemployment rate rose to 4.3%. The jobs report sparked fears that the Fed may have waited too long to cut interest rates and risked damaging the economy. Fed Chair Jerome Powell used his Jackson Hole speech to signal an interest rate cut in September, and the Federal Open Market Committee followed through with a 50bps cut.
Elsewhere, the Bank of England and the European Central Bank also cut rates by 25bps in the quarter. In contrast, the Bank of Japan surprised the market by raising rates, resulting in a stronger yen and triggering an unwinding of a popular US dollar-Japanese yen carry trade, which caused a short-lived spike in volatility.
Markets experienced a style and sector performance rotation in Q3. Looking at the Russell 1000® Index, performance in the first half of the year was dominated by a narrow set of US mega-cap winners (the Magnificent Seven). To put this into context, if you were to remove the Magnificent Seven companies from the Russell 1000® Index, the total return would fall from 14.0% to 7.8%. This narrow leadership meant growth outperformed value, large caps outperformed small caps, and sector performance was led by information technology and communication services. Results in Q3 were the opposite: value outperformed growth, small caps outperformed large caps, and previously shunned sectors, such as utilities and real estate, gained renewed favor with investors.
Although US markets were robust, non-US markets also saw gains, most notably emerging markets. Late in the quarter, the People’s Bank of China announced a major stimulus package that led to one of the sharpest and most concentrated rallies in Chinese market history, as investors hoped the measures would reinvigorate the world’s second-largest economy.
Performance Discussion
Our portfolio underperformed the MSCI AC World Index in Q3. Looking at sector attribution, allocation headwinds and negative security selection drove underperformance.
From an allocation perspective, the portfolio’s underweight to financials, utilities and consumer staples detracted from relative results. Security selection weakness was concentrated within health care and consumer discretionary. Several health care holdings, including Novo Nordisk (NVO), Dexcom (DXCM) and West Pharmaceutical Services (WST), experienced idiosyncratic challenges. However, the drag on performance from those holdings was partially offset by our biotechnology holding, Argenx (ARGX), which we will discuss later. Partially offsetting the weakness in health care and consumer discretionary was outperformance within industrials and communication services.
Among our top detractors were Dexcom and Novo Nordisk. Dexcom is the leader in continuous glucose-monitoring (CGM) systems. With data increasingly supporting the clinical and economic case for CGMs, we believe Dexcom is well positioned to further penetrate the Type 1 diabetes market and to drive adoption in the much larger Type 2 diabetes market. Unfortunately, financial results showed meaningful growth deceleration, and shares responded accordingly. The company pointed to several causes for the surprising slowdown, most of which were execution related (e.g., sales force changes and distribution channel mismanagement) in the context of healthy industry trends. For example, the company rolled out a direct-to-consumer glucose monitor that distracted from the company’s commercial business. While we continue to believe in the case for CGMs and Dexcom’s technology, the lack of execution is concerning. We believe these operational mistakes will take time, and we decided to exit our position.
Novo Nordisk has leading positions in diabetes and obesity, and it has consistently innovated in these areas. While the diabetes business should continue delivering solid growth, our core investment thesis is centered around the company entering a big profit cycle driven by its GLP1 drugs, namely its Wegovy® offering. After a multiyear period of strong performance, shares have experienced recent weakness.
Prescription volumes remain exceptionally strong, and the company remains supply-constrained to match demand (the drug remains on the FDA’s drug shortage list). However, larger-than-expected pricing discounts have weighed on recent earnings results. We trimmed the position early in the quarter due to our valuation discipline and again after the earnings results showed signs of a more mature profit cycle and uncertainty around the trajectory of pricing declines.
Among our top Q3 contributors were Argenx and Tencent (OTCPK:TCEHY). Shares of Argenx have rallied this year due to multiple positive developments. The company recently received FDA approval to promote VYVGART® for chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy (CIDP). We expect this to be the drug’s second blockbuster indication since it is the first meaningful advance in CIDP treatment in decades. Meanwhile, VYVGART®’s first approved indication in myasthenia gravis continues to shine. With sales beating analyst expectations, we believe the size of the myasthenia gravis opportunity will continue to yield upside longer term. Lastly, the company is investing in clinical trials studying VYVGART® in numerous other rare autoimmune disorders and is making good progress in advancing its second breakthrough medicine.
Tencent is a Chinese Internet company best known for its WeChat messaging service, which has more than one billion monthly active users. The company monetizes its users through various services (e.g., PC and mobile games, digital content subscriptions) and offers cloud software, payments and advertising for enterprises. These services benefit from a broad range of long-duration profit cycle drivers.
However, its shares underperformed for multiple years due to regulatory risk in China. We slowly built a Garden SM position through 2023 at what we viewed as an extremely depressed valuation level. In recent quarters, we have been building conviction due to improved visibility in its gaming pipeline, accelerating advertising growth and management returning capital to shareholders. The company and much of the broader Chinese market experienced a sharp rally toward the end of the quarter after the Chinese government announced a series of stimulus measures to combat decelerating growth caused by property market challenges and poor consumer sentiment.
Portfolio Activity
During the quarter, we initiated new Garden SM positions in Sea (SE) and Unilever (UL). Sea is a Singapore-based Internet company with primary operations across Southeast Asia and Taiwan. Its integrated platforms include online games, e-commerce and digital payment services. We initiated a position as the company appeared out of favor over the past couple of years despite reporting strong fundamental results, including strong growth in gross merchandise volume, e-commerce revenue, active gaming users and financial services revenue. Importantly, we have been closely monitoring TikTok (which partnered with Tokopedia to relaunch TikTok Shop in Indonesia) as a potential threat but see no signs of rising competitive intensity.
Unilever is one of the largest global consumer packaged goods companies across five business segments: beauty and wellbeing, personal care, home care, nutrition and ice cream. We believe the company is in the early innings of significant internal changes that will drive a profit cycle fueled by higher volumes and margins. The company has hired new management, changed the incentive compensation structure to drive performance, developed a strategy that places a greater emphasis on investing in the company’s fastest growing brands and has stated its intention to divest underperforming assets.
Notable adds in the quarter included Oracle (ORCL) and Nike (NKE). Oracle has become a leading global enterprise software provider with more than 400,000 customers and products utilized by 100% of the Fortune 100. We believe the company is entering an interesting profit cycle as its faster growing business units become a larger percentage of the revenue mix. Most notably, Oracle Cloud Infrastructure (OCI) has gone through a significant product upgrade cycle that will enable it to be the primary incremental top-line growth driver. The company is winning new accounts due to its attractive pricing, flexibility and expanding geographic availability. Also, within its SaaS segment, we believe the company will benefit from the secular trend to cloud computing. Oracle experiences a significant profit uplift as it moves its on-premise database business to the cloud (through any cloud provider). As this revenue is migrated, it will become highly accretive to profit margins. The company recently surprised investors by announcing a 2029 revenue target of $104 billion, which implies an acceleration in annual revenue growth to ~16% from the current ~9%–10% levels. Given an attractive valuation and what we feel is a long-term visible path of revenue acceleration, we added to the position.
Nike, the global leader in athletic footwear and apparel, generates revenue from a balanced mix of wholesale and direct-to-consumer channels. The company’s historical success can be attributed to its proprietary R&D, athlete endorsements, marketing strategies and strong bargaining power against suppliers. After a period of challenging results, we believe the company is entering an interesting inflection period. During the COVID-19 environment, the company thrived given its strategic focus on the direct-to-consumer channel.
However, the company has struggled since the pandemic due to neglected relationships with distribution partners and a lack of focus on product innovation. Despite recent disappointing results, we believe Nike’s competitive advantages remain intact. The company’s innovation pipeline is gaining momentum, coinciding with improving product lifecycle management and organizational restructuring. We see significant upside potential at current valuation levels if Nike can reignite brand heat and stimulate consumer demand for its new products, but it will remain a Garden SM position until our thesis begins to show tangible evidence.
Along with Dexcom, we ended our investment campaigns in Vestas Wind Systems (OTCPK:VWDRY) and Hexagon (OTCPK:HXGBF) during the quarter. Our thesis was that Vestas would be well positioned to capitalize on the secular trend toward a less carbon-intensive world, given its ability to produce onshore wind turbines at a low cost without relying on subsidies. Investors had been wary of the company due to challenging returns on capital as it struggled with supply chain instability and cost inflation in raw materials, transport and turbine components.
However, we believed several of these headwinds would prove to be transitory, and the company was operating in a more benign competitive environment as key competitors faced company-specific issues. Unfortunately, recent earnings results continued to be disappointing, and we exited the position in favor of more attractive alternatives.
Hexagon is a global leader in design, measurement and visualization technology used in manufacturing, product testing, surveying and machine controls. The company’s integrated software and hardware solutions help manufacturers across a variety of industries improve quality and productivity by increasing the precision and speed with which products are designed and manufactured. We decided to exit the position due to disappointing earnings results and a lack of any new identifiable catalysts from here that would turn things around.
Along with Novo Nordisk, notable trims in the quarter included Atlassian (TEAM) and NU Holdings (NU). Atlassian is a provider of collaboration and productivity software tools—a large, structurally growing addressable market that is expanding from the core software developer market to a much larger “knowledge worker” market. However, along with much of the software industry, the company has come under pressure from softer small and medium-sized business spending due to macroeconomic headwinds, along with shifting enterprise IT spending toward AI projects at the expense of traditional cloud software offerings. While we continue to have conviction longer term, we decided to reduce the position until we have more clarity on these headwinds.
Through its subsidiaries, NU Holdings provides loans and digital banking services primarily in Brazil, and more recently in Mexico and Columbia. Nubank was created to address the limited access to financial services and terrible customer service by Brazil’s largest banks. Unlike the US, with over 4,000 banks, Brazil, Mexico and Columbia have highly concentrated banking systems. Not only do these legacy banks lag in terms of technology and innovation, but they also carry the high costs of physical branches and related staffing. Nubank is a completely digital online bank. Our research indicates that it has lower customer acquisition, customer servicing and credit costs than its large competitors. We believe Nubank will continue to generate attractive growth as it can add customers at high rates, not only from targeting legacy bank customers but also serving the populations that legacy banks can’t or won’t. Shares have rallied significantly this year, and we trimmed the position due to our valuation discipline.
Stewardship Update
In 2024, our team has been spending more time learning about key water sustainability issues—from not only the business risks presented by water challenges but also the opportunities for companies that help to address these challenges. One specific area we have been researching is water contamination from PFAS (per- and poly-fluoroalkyl substances) in drinking water. These chemicals were widely used in various industrial applications, including nonstick cookware, fire-fighting foams and stain repellents. The problem is that these chemicals do not break down easily and can contaminate water sources for many years, and studies have linked PFAS exposure to various health issues.
To combat this, governments are in the very early stages of implementing stricter regulations (and providing funding) to limit the use and release of PFAS and advocating for advanced water treatment technologies to remove PFAS from drinking water. As awareness and regulations regarding the health risks associated with PFAS contamination increase, the need for effective solutions to remove these chemicals from drinking water also grows. For example, recent news publications have pointed to the contamination of farmland due to the utilization of “sludge fertilizer” sourced from municipal sewage systems. When a fertilizer containing PFAS is applied to farmland, the chemicals get into the soil and water. This creates a market opportunity for companies that provide filtration systems, water treatment services, testing and monitoring equipment, and technical consulting services, such as Ecolab and Xylem.
Perspective
After months of speculation, the market received its much hoped-for first interest rate cut, justifying the year-to-date fall in the two-year US Treasury yield of 61bps (from 4.25% to 3.64%). It is still up for debate how far these cuts will go given the wide range of future possibilities, including an economic hard landing that brings a recession and aggressive Fed rate cutting, a soft landing with modest growth and controlled inflation, and a “no landing” where the Fed is unable to move much further due to stubborn inflationary pressures. We are not making a prediction but will monitor these trends closely.
In general, even if the rate-cutting cycle proves modest, we believe it is healthy for businesses exposed to construction and real estate. For example, Ferguson (FERG) and CoStar Group (CSGP) have been pressured in recent years by high mortgage rates and challenging commercial real estate fundamentals, but we believe those dynamics are starting to ease, and we could be entering an attractive new cycle.
Of course, the looming US election will likely have at least some impact on markets, especially in areas such as renewable energy, antitrust regulation and corporate tax rates. While we believe certain portfolio holdings would be advantaged or disadvantaged by certain election outcomes, our experience has taught us not to position the portfolio for a specific result.
At a sector level, we think the most important market debate going forward is the strength of spending on AI. We will be closely watching to see if the large AI investments made by companies translate to productivity gains or competitive advantages. If they are, AI capital expenditures will likely continue to be strong. However, future spending could be at risk if these investments do not yield real results. We are focused on AI enablers that we believe remain well positioned to benefit from reasonable (not even the best case) industry investment levels because they are gaining market share based on superior technologies (e.g., higher speed and/or lower power), such as Taiwan Semiconductor (TSM), Advanced Micro Devices (AMD), ARM Holdings (ARM) and Arista Networks (ANET). Within industrials, electrification enablers like Eaton and Quanta Service are well-placed to benefit from not only AI data center construction but also the national need for more extensive and reliable electrical grids to support the energy transition. While we expect some volatility in AI-exposed stocks given relatively lofty expectations, we are being disciplined on valuations and are optimistic these can be attractive investments over time.
Read the full article here